To unlock the following trophies, play the following rivalry games as either of the two teams.
| Unlockable |
How to Unlock |
| Administaff Bayou Bucket Trophy |
Houston vs. Rice |
| Apple Cup Trophy |
Washington vs. Washington St. |
| Black Diamond Trophy |
West Virginia vs Virginia Tech |
| Commonwealth Cup Trophy |
Virginia vs. Virginia Tech |
| Golden Boot Trophy |
Arkansas vs. LSU |
| Golden Egg Trophy |
Mississippi St. vs. Ole Miss |
| Golden Hat Trophy |
Oklahoma vs. Texas |
| Ireland Trophy |
Boston College vs. Notre Dame |
| Jeweled Shillelagh Trophy |
Notre Dame vs. USC |
| Little Brown Jug Trophy |
Michigan vs. Minnesota |
| Marching Drum Trophy |
Kansas vs. Missouri |
| Megaphone Trophy |
Michigan St. vs. Notre Dame |
| Old Brass Spittoon Trophy |
Indiana vs. Michigan St. |
| Old Oaken Bucket Trophy |
Indiana vs. Purdue |
| Paul Bunyan's Axe Trophy |
Minnesota vs. Wisconsin |
| Silver Spade Trophy |
New Mexico vs. New Mexico St. |
| Stanford Axe Trophy |
Cal vs. Stanford |
| Sweet Sioux Tomahawk Trophy |
Illinois vs. Northwestern |
| Territorrial Cup Trophy |
Arizona vs. Arizona St. |
| Victory Bell Trophy |
UCLA vs. USC |
| Victory Bell Trophy |
Cincinatti vs. Miami (OH) |
