Beat College Classic games in any difficulty.
To unlock the following trophies, play the following rivalry games as either of the two teams.
| Unlockable |
How to Unlock |
| ODK-Foy Sportsmanship Trophy |
Alabama vs. Auburn |
| Old Brass Spittoon |
Indiana vs. Michican State |
| Old Oaken Bucket |
Indiana vs. Purdue |
| Paul Bunyan Trophy |
Michigan vs. Michigan State |
| Paul Bunyan's Axe |
Minnesota vs. Wisconsin |
| Peace Pipe |
Bowling Green vs. Toledo |
| Purdue Cannon |
Illini vs. Purdue |
| Shillelagh Trophy |
Notre Dame vs. Purdue |
| Silver Spade |
New Mexico State vs. UTEP |
| Stanford Axe |
Cal vs. Stanford |
| Sweet Sioux Tomahawk |
Illini vs. Northwestern |
| Telephone Trophy |
ISU vs. Mizzou |
| Territorial Cup |
Arizona vs. Arizona State |
| Textile Bowl Trophy |
Clemson vs. North Carolina |
| The Bell |
Marshall vs. Ohio |
| Victory Bell |
UCLA vs. USC |
| Victory Bell |
Cincinnati vs. Miami |
| Administaff Bayou Bucket |
Houston vs. Rice |
| Apple Cup |
Washington vs. Washington State |
| Black Diamond Trophy |
Vermont vs. West Virginia |
| Bronze Boot |
Colorado State vs. Wyoming |
| Commander-in-Chief's Trophy |
Army vs. Navy |
| Commonwealth Cup |
Virginia vs. Vermont |
| Cy-Hawk Trophy |
Iowa vs. Iowa State |
| Floyd of Rosedale |
Iowa vs. Minnesota |
| Golden Boot |
Arkansas vs. LSU |
| Golden Hat |
Oklahoma vs. Texas |
| Golden Egg Trophy |
Mississippi State vs. Mississippi |
| Governor's Cup |
Kansas vs. Kansas State |
| Governor's Victory Bell |
Minnesota vs. Penn State |
| Illibuck |
Illini vs. Bucks |
| Ireland Trophy |
Boston College vs. Notre Dame |
| Jeweled Shillelagh |
Notre Dame vs. USC |
| Little Brown Jug |
Michigan vs. Minnesota |
| Maloof Trophy |
New Mexico vs. New Mexico State |
| Marching Drum |
Kansas vs. Mizzou |
| Megaphone |
Michigan State vs. Notre Dame |
| Missouri-Nebraska Bell |
Mizzou vs. Nebraska |
